The Lost World was Michael Crichton’s follow-up to Jurassic Park, and naturally, it quickly received a movie adaptation directed by Steven Spielberg-but like with Spielberg’s “Jurassic Park”, several changes were made between page and screen. Both novel and film deal with Ian Malcolm and others stumbling upon a second Dinosaur island-Site B, or “Isla Sorna”-which was the large-scale laboratory and factory complex for Jurassic Park, and are filled with a lot of Dinosaur awe and action, but apart from that, novel and film differ quite a bit. Let’s start with the characters-the good guys, or, as Steven Spielberg put it, “The gatherers”.
Ian Malcolm
First things first, Ian Malcolm ‘sort of’ dies in the first “Jurassic Park” novel, but Michael Crichton, perhaps encouraged by the popularity of Jeff Goldblum’s take on the character, or realizing that maybe Alan Grant or some other new protagonist wouldn’t really be able to communicate the complex issues communicated in the novels, “resurrected” Malcolm, revealing that although he suffered a leg injury, he managed to somehow escape Jurassic Park before it was sterilized, and despite Muldoon implying he was a goner.
In the TLW novel, Malcolm begins to see evidence from one of his colleagues, Dr. Richard Levine, that there’s another Dinosaur island out there, although he’s initially reluctant to tell Levine of his involvement in Jurassic Park. Nonetheless, he’s intrigued, and when Levine goes missing on Isla Sorna, he likewise goes to the Island, with two other men-Dr. Thorne and Eddie Carr, scheduled to join Levine’s expedition-to find Levine and discovery the mystery of Isla Sorna.
There’s a bit of a divergence here. Like in the book, film Malcolm goes to the island to search for a missing paleontologist-but in that case it’s his girlfriend Sarah Harding. Likewise, film Ian went public with the events of Jurassic Park, to initial public disbelief (which has faded by the time the Dinosaurs were public anyway by film’s end).
Ian’s attitude is also completely different once he arrives. In the film, he’s desperate to get off the island, something which is accelerated even further when it turns out not only is Sarah on the island, but his daughter Kelly as well.
In the novel, he pretty much is in no hurry whatsoever, somewhat relishing the opportunity to study these creatures, much like Levine…and also to study a theory of extinction he’s developing in his head….until the latter events of the novel, where he suffers yet another T-rex related injury, and the Raptors start attacking everyone, leading Sarah to call for an evacuation helicopter. In the novel, he also surmises that the Dinosaurs are dying anyway, due to Ingen’s poor feeding techniques which have led to an outbreak on the island, and that perhaps the Dinosaurs-which were nurtured in a lab and not naturally grown-may be a poor basis for his study anyway (as he notices the Raptors are particularly vicious).
Sarah Harding
Julianne Moore’s Sarah is a combination of two characters from the novel, her namesake and Richard Levine. Novel Sarah is an animal behaviorist, and although a former girlfriend of Malcolms and aware of the expedition to Site B, doesn’t initially believe the Dinosaur stories until she sees them in the flesh. Her way to the island is a bit different; instead of going early to the island (like Levine), she hitches a ride with the villains Dodgson, King and Baselton, unaware that they’re bad guys from Biosyn who want to steal Dinosaur eggs and use them for their own Dinosaur genetic experiments….they throw her overboard once they’re close to the island, but she manages to survive and reunites with Malcolm and co. Like in the film, she assists in tending to the injured young T-rex, and is attacked as well. She seems a bit more ‘badass’ than their film counterpart, as well, although Moore did have some pretty good scenes here and there.
Levine’s inspiration for the character is the paleontologist aspect, as well as the character’s somewhat over-the-top giddiness, occasional frustration and sometimes clumsy field work (The NIKON camera incident for instance, and the bloody jacket, although neither happened to Levine, Levine still makes many other errors, including one incident that gets his initial guide killed).
The combination also makes Sarah an expert in “Paleontological behavior study” which sort of mixes her two professions together (and is “sort of” a real thing, although of course based a lot on theory and conjecture since we don’t have actual living Dinosaurs apart from their evolutionary descendants, birds!).
Book Sarah also gets to ride a motorcycle against Raptors (and around a herd of apatosaurs), something used in concept art for the film but ultimately left out for her….
We just get this random guy instead.
Although Jurassic World would also use similar imagery, but the Raptors working with the main characters (well, at least at first).
Eddie Carr/Nick Van Owen
Now here’s where things get a bit more complicated. There’s no “Nick Van Owen” in the novel, but there is an Eddie Carr. However, novel Eddie is the assistant to Dr. Thorne, a character that does not appear in the film…..however, many of film Eddie’s technical skill-the rifle, the trailers, High Hide etc. are Thorne’s work in the novel, and Eddie is mainly his assistant. It’s also Thorne who helps to rescue Ian and Sarah from the T-rex trailer attack, much like Eddie in the film. Some of novel Eddie’s mannerisms are incorporated into Nick Van Owen; his sense of humor to a degree (although not his environmentalist background) and perhaps most importantly, Eddie’s the one who saves the infant T-rex and brings it to the trailer, much like Nick in the film. However, whereas Nick survives in the film, both versions of Eddie die; novel Eddie falls over the high hide during a Raptor attack and becomes Raptor food; Film Eddie is torn apart by the Tyrannosaurs during the rescue attempt.
Kelly
Kelly is another character that’s kind of a mix between other characters. Two of Levine’s students, Kelly and Arby, stow away on the trailer much like Kelly does, although unlike movie Kelly, there is no family relationship to Malcolm. There’s also no rush at first for them to leave the island, until the Raptors attack; and Kelly also finds herself looking up to Sarah much like her movie counterpart, and also saves the day; although in the novel, it’s not gymnastics, but her locating a crawlspace and boathouse (after the rescue helicopter decides to leave) that allows the characters to escape-and just in time, too.
Hammond
…..is still dead in the book-verse; despite Malcolm’s miraculous recovery, Hammond stays dead, as he was killed off in the original novel….Hammond in the original novel is portrayed as a very greedy man who is unwilling to believe anything could possibly go wrong; while the movie version displays this arrogance for a bit, the novel version is a far colder, dangerous man and in many ways is more of a villain than Nedry, and gets killed by falling into a ditch and getting eaten by compsonathus, while the movie version repents of his park, although he still wishes to preserve the Dinosaurs in Site B (although not in a park), and before his death, tasked Masereti with reviving Jurassic Park with Jurassic World.
Some of Hammond’s greedy traits from the first book are incorporated into TLW’s villain, his nephew Peter Ludow…
but his death in the JP novel is pretty similar to Dietar Stark’s demise in TLW (Although Dietar’s death also shares some similarities with Peter King’s death in the novel; I’ll go on about that in a separate article).